Lynda Silsbee, Founder, Alliance for Leadership Acceleration and the Leadership Acceleration Program. Organizational effectiveness expert
I’ve been hearing this question a lot, and I’m sure I’m not the only one wondering: Will AI replace executive coaches?
Short answer? No. Longer answer? Not if we evolve.
Artificial intelligence is already changing how we work, think and lead—and yes, it’s stepping into the coaching space, too. There are AI tools that can now offer feedback on communication style, assess leadership strengths, generate reflection questions and even simulate coaching conversations. And they’re improving fast. But let’s not panic. Instead, let’s get curious.
For this article, I’m diving into the pros and cons of AI in executive coaching—and offering actionable tips to help us stay relevant, credible and deeply human in an AI-accelerated world.
What AI Can Do For Coaches
Let’s start with the good news. AI is not the enemy or our competition. In fact, it can be our new best assistant. Here are some ways AI can help:
• Scalable Support: AI can help scale the reach of coaching. Virtual platforms with embedded AI can provide micro-learning, track habit formation and prompt reflection between sessions, which is especially useful for clients in fast-moving roles or organizations rolling out coaching across tiers of leadership.
• Real-Time Insights: Some tools analyze tone, sentiment and language patterns during conversations, helping clients (and coaches) identify blind spots. Imagine receiving a report that says, “You interrupted 30% more than usual in this meeting.” Powerful.
• Data-Driven Feedback: AI tools can synthesize data from 360s, engagement surveys or leadership assessments to identify themes faster and more objectively. This allows us to spend more time coaching and less time aggregating reports. I love it!
• On-Demand Reflection: AI-generated journaling prompts or chat-based “AI coaches” can keep clients engaged between sessions and reinforce coaching topics, helping to close the “knowing versus doing” gap.
What AI Can’t Replace
And now, the heart of the matter. AI can simulate aspects of coaching, but it can’t be a coach. It can’t do what we humans do best, including:
• Deep Empathy And Intuition: An algorithm can’t look a client in the eye (yet), sense the emotional weight behind their silence or pause at just the right moment to let a breakthrough surface. Empathy isn’t just emotion—it’s presence, nuance and attunement.
• Context And Complexity: Coaching is rarely about simple answers. It’s about exploring competing priorities, organizational politics, personal histories and unwritten rules. AI may offer frameworks, but it struggles with paradox.
• Trust And Relationship: The power of coaching lies in trust: the safety we create, the belief we hold for someone, the way we challenge them because we care. That kind of transformative relationship can’t be coded.
• Ethics And Judgment: Executive coaching often involves messy, high-stakes decisions. Ethics, judgment and values are central to the conversations. AI isn’t ready to navigate moral gray areas with grace and integrity.
Staying Relevant In The AI Age
So, how do we keep our edge as coaches when AI is getting smarter by the second? We double down on what makes us uniquely human—and learn to partner with the technology, not compete with it. Here are five tips all coaches can use:
1. Be tech-savvy, not tech-phobic.
Understand the tools your clients might be using—AI writing assistants, leadership dashboards or behavior tracking apps. Experiment with AI tools that can enhance your prep or session planning. Speak the language.
2. Lead with insight, not information.
Information is abundant. Insight is rare. Your value comes from helping leaders make sense of their world, not just from delivering models or frameworks. Dig deeper. Ask sharper questions. Bring new lenses.
3. Go deeper into the human side.
The more AI performs the tasks, the more leaders need help with the intangibles—confidence, vulnerability, values, courage, meaning. Be the coach who helps them lead from the inside out.
4. Measure impact, not just activity.
As organizations grow and become more data-driven, they’ll expect coaches to demonstrate value. Define success metrics up front. Then collect a baseline measurement. Revisit goals and success metrics to see if you’re moving the needle. Link coaching to business outcomes, culture shifts or leadership pipeline strength.
5. Be a thought partner, not just a cheerleader.
Your clients don’t need someone to simply affirm their brilliance. They need a trusted partner who’ll challenge their thinking, help them see the bigger picture and nudge them toward growth even when it’s uncomfortable.
Final Thoughts
AI is absolutely changing the landscape of coaching. But rather than fearing displacement, we should see this as a call to grow and evolve professionally. Coaches who embrace both head and heart—who blend data with wisdom, insight with empathy—will thrive.
So, will AI replace coaches? Only the ones who coach like robots.
Let’s stay real, stay curious and keep doing the deep work that only humans can do.
Forbes Coaches Council is an invitation-only community for leading business and career coaches. Do I qualify?
